Did Mawiah Face Any Accountability During The Rein Of First Three Caliphs? - MoCity

MoCity - Muslim Online > Mo University > Sectarian Debate (Sunni/Shia/Wahabi/Sufi/etc.)

FORUM RULES

WARNING: IF YOU ARE NEW TO ISLAM OR DON'T HAVE MUCH KNOWLEDGE ABOUT THE SUNNI/SHIA CONFLICT, PLEASE STAY OUT OF THIS SECTION. IT IS MEANT FOR ADVANCED USERS ONLY.

RULES

1) In order for this section to succeed and bring about learning, we need respect for all members regardless of their beliefs.
PLEASE SHOW RESPECT TO ONE ANOTHER and debate in a good manner.

2) DO NOT accuse any members of lying. Any one who does so will be warned.

3) This is a debate section, we DO NOT use personal attacks on each other nor do we ''name call'' (e.g nasibi's, rafidhs etc.)

4) Once again this being a debate section we do not use humour/sarcasm to annoy/aggravate members. (e.g LOOOL, AHAHA etc.) Also use of emoticons is banned in interfaith.

5) When posting your arguments make sure you provide evidence and credible sources. (When copying&pasting do not post anything longer than 2 paragraphs please post link only)

6) You may criticise and debate against the Prophet's Wives, Sunni Caliphs, and Shia Imams. However, NO insulting, hating, cursing, or slander against these people

7) Most importantly this is a debate section NOT a warzone.

These rules apply to ALL, the rules will strictly be enforced.

3 Pages

< 1 2 3

Did Mawiah Face Any Accountability During The Rein Of First Three Caliphs?, Did Mawiah ever face any accountability during the rein of three calip

Options

Nafs-az-Zakiyah

I Might As Well Marry A MoCitizen

Group: MoGovernator
Posts: 1,002

Representing: Canada
Religion: Islam: Sunni
Gender:

Nov 20 2010, 04:01 PM

Post #41

QUOTE(Kalaam @ Nov 15 2010, 11:03 PM)

who translated this by the way? where is the bold arabic text in the translation? and where is the bold text in the translation in the arabic text? you present things from the website of deceivers? fear Allah and don't trust shias when it comes to sahaba. they lie more than any cult.

I don't trust a shia or a sunni when it comes to these sensitive issues. They both have their tactics. However, what I wanted to see if how the person who started the topic would react. So far he has just presented his emotions and hatred toward the 3 calipahs. He then rejected all my sources I provided. Then when I give him a link to a shia blog he is asked me to check the sources further. If the brother can't even provide any references himself why does he have double standards? He starts his topic by saying the calipahs allowed 100%+ corruption, but he didn't even provide one reference for this. To be honest, you would be a better debator against him then me. I will give you credit for that.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Nafs-az-Zakiyah

I Might As Well Marry A MoCitizen

Group: MoGovernator
Posts: 1,002

Representing: Canada
Religion: Islam: Sunni
Gender:

Nov 21 2010, 11:48 AM

Post #42

Brother Bar please focus on the topic. Don't go off tangents. You started a topic, yet since you have no answer you are going off topic. This topic you started is about what the 3 calipahs against Muwaiyah's injustice. Its not about what is a calipah and what isn't. Also its ironic how you quote tabari, but previously you rejected it. I love the double standards.

This post has been edited by Nafs-az-Zakiyah: Nov 21 2010, 11:49 AM

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------