Sikh cursing caliphs, and ensuing dialogue - MoCity

MoCity - Muslim Online > Mo University > Opposing Religions Debate (Christianity/Islam/Hindu/etc)

Talk and/or Debate, But Don't Hate

Sikh cursing caliphs, and ensuing dialogue, split as being OT in another thread

Options

Killed Bill

You Douchebag.

Group: MoVicePresident
Posts: 3,588

Representing: Afghanistan
Religion: Not Specified
Gender:

Jul 14 2007, 08:35 PM

Post #1

QUOTE(Nafs-az-Zakiyah @ Jul 15 2007, 01:51 AM)

Sister Aliya
Do not resign just people disagree with you. Besides they have only brought out points from shiachat. On shiachat you have to be pro shia or else you might loose your job. Just like on kr-hcy you have to be against the Shia aqeeda to be a mod. Anyway, Sunni brothers i encourage you to give sister Aliya a chance on this forum. I remember once a sikh on shiachat kept cursing the first 3 calipah and most of the mods ignored it. However, Aliya came in and warned him. So I think we should give her a change on this forum.

Agreed.

Why was a Sikh cursing the 3 Caliphs???

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Nafs-az-Zakiyah

I Might As Well Marry A MoCitizen

Group: MoGovernator
Posts: 1,002

Representing: Canada
Religion: Islam: Sunni
Gender:

Jul 14 2007, 10:54 PM

Post #2

I dunno. There is a sikh on the forum who believes that he is true shia of Ali. His views have evolved over time too. He even started a forum combining the beliefs of 12rs, ismailis, Sufis and Sikhs.

I mean he respects agha khan who has mixed secular belief in the ismailis aqeeda, but curses the first 3 calipahs to prove that he is shia.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Guest_Sapahi_*

MoTourists

Gender:

Jul 15 2007, 08:10 AM

Post #3

Huh a sikh?!?!?!?!?!?! What the heck!!!! If he wants to revert to Islam thats all good, but to speak about things he doesnt even know is just crazy lol!

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Nafs-az-Zakiyah

I Might As Well Marry A MoCitizen

Group: MoGovernator
Posts: 1,002

Representing: Canada
Religion: Islam: Sunni
Gender:

Jul 15 2007, 01:58 PM

Post #4

Yes and it seems like this user started his own sufi cult by mixing the beliefs of ismailis, 12rs, sufis and sikhs into one.

http://www.nuralimam.net/

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Sunni Phalanx

Son of the Mother of the Believers

Group: MoResident
Posts: 66

Representing: No Answer
Religion: Islam: Sunni
Gender:

Jul 18 2007, 08:50 AM

Post #5

What's so surprising about Sikhs attacking the Companions of the Prophet [s]? In fact, the Kufaar have always done this, starting from the Jews, Christian Orientalists, Hindus, Sikhs, etc. What is so odd about it? I don't get it? The best way to attack the Prophet [s] is by attacking his wives, family, and Companions! That's the way you can tell an enemy of Islam: if he attacks the Sahabah.

QUOTE

Yes and it seems like this user started his own sufi cult by mixing the beliefs of ismailis, 12rs, sufis and sikhs into one.

And what's so surprising about a guy created a new sect to diss the companions of the Prophet [s]? What's so strange about a guy creating a new religion by mixing the beliefs of Islam with other religions such as Zoroastrianism, or Sikhism in this case?

That's not something new. It's been done before. Very effective way of creating Fitnah.

This post has been edited by Ahl as-Sunnah: Jul 18 2007, 08:52 AM

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------